Preaching and Preachers podcast image

Preaching and Preachers

By Dr. Jason K. Allen

Preaching and Preachers is the official podcast of Dr. Jason Allen, the president of Midwestern Seminary.

Subscribe on iTunesSubscribe on StitcherSubscribe on AndroidPodcast RSS

Follow Preaching and Preachers on Social Media

A Conversation with Danny Akin about Theological Education*

Audio: A Conversation with Danny Akin on Theological Education

Transcript:

Dr. Allen:

It is a joy to have with me in the Spurgeon Room today Dr. Danny Akin, president of Southeastern Seminary. We are here in the Spurgeon Room on the campus of Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary in the basement of the President’s home—the Vivion Home—where we have the Spurgeon Room as a part of my library. We have excerpts from C. H. Spurgeon’s library here on display. It is fun to be in this room and to talk about preaching and things of concern for the Great Commission, the denomination, and different topics of interest.

Today, I want to talk about theological education in the Southern Baptist context. I confess that I am the newbie to the table. I am a young man, elected not too long ago, in my mid-30s. I serve with men who are much older than me, much wiser than me, who have been around much longer. One of those men is Dr. Danny Akin. It is a unique joy to have you in the context of this conversation, Danny. You were a professor of mine a number of years ago, and you have been serving roughly a decade as president of Southeastern Seminary.

What I want to talk about is theological education in the Southern Baptist context. When you think about the stewardship that we have; when you think about the fact that roughly 40 percent of seminary students in Evangelical seminaries today—or we should say, in non-Catholic seminaries in North America—are in Southern Baptist Seminaries; when you think about the largest Protestant denomination in America—about 16 million Southern Baptists, located in about 46,000 Southern Baptist churches, who have six seminaries, an incredible stewardship is there.

Then, when you factor in our own denominational narrative—the history that has taken place over the past 155 years—you have a convention founded in 1845 that started its first seminary is 1859, under the vision of James P. Boyce. Over the next century, it would add five more seminaries. To a greater or lesser degree, all six of those became wayward theologically in the context of the 20th century. Then, all of those were recovered theologically through the efforts of Paige Patterson, Paul Pressler, and most visibly, through Adrian Rogers and other pastors. The seminaries were recovered and restored to their confessional roots, primarily the Baptist Faith and Message 2000.

So, here we are in 2013, seeking to serve a denomination that has this history, that has this potential, that has entrusted us with this incredible kingdom stewardship. It is a denomination that is diverse, that is eclectic, that is, in a sense, incredibly diverse, while it is incredibly unified. We are unified around conviction about the Great Commission, reaching the world for Christ, and belief in the Bible. When you look at where the convention stands as it relates to other denominations, we actually are incredibly unified in that sense, but when you work back from that convictional uniformity, with so many churches, being a free-church movement and a bottom-up denomination—it is an eclectic group.

So, here we are seeking to be faithful. Tell us the way you assess our job in the year 2013, the season we are serving within, and how we undertake this task most faithfully.

Dr. Akin:

The simplest job description for us, Jason, is that we are called to serve the churches of the Southern Baptist Convention. You are right: we are a bottom-up denomination. The churches do not serve us, we serve them. If we are not serving the churches well, then we forfeit our right to exist. I think it is imperative that we never lose sight of that. Will there be times when we speak prophetically into the life of the churches? Yes, I think that is true. However, the bottom line is that we respond to their requests for service, so our goal and our calling is to serve them and to serve them well.

How can we serve them well? I think primarily it is through integrity in theological and biblical studies. We serve them well as we send back to them well-trained ministers, faithful expositors, evangelists, men and women with missionary hearts who are grounded theologically and who know what they believe and why they believe it. They do so robustly and ecclesiastically, under the umbrella of our Baptist Faith and Message 2000.

I know some people think that it is too elastic of a statement, but actually, if you think about it, it is pretty narrow. In fact, in the grand scheme of things, it is very narrow. You have to affirm an inerrant Bible. You have to affirm the exclusivity of the gospel. You have to affirm penal substitution. You have to affirm a regenerate church. You have to affirm the sanctity of life from conception to natural death. You have to affirm the sanctity of heterosexual marriage, and you have to affirm the complementary nature of marriage. That is a lot of stuff to agree upon. We really do have a very unified voice. Yes, there are differences in terms of soteriological emphases and eschatological positions, differences in how we understand church government with respect to plurality of elders versus single pastors, and some other areas as well, but we really do have a substantial body of theological conviction and truth that we are united on.

Dr. Allen:

Absolutely. Sometimes folks have asked me, “Given that we are such a diverse denomination, how can we work together?” I say, “Are you kidding me? How can we not work together when you think about where we are?” We have one driving mission—to reach the world for Christ. We have a bedrock of shared convictions that is all based upon an inerrant Bible and a confessional statement derived from that. You put those two realities there and you say, “Oh, by the way, we have a world that is deeply and increasingly entrenched in a secular mindset that will become more and more adverse to who we are and what we do as believers in Christ.”

We are going to be in a situation here very soon, as you think about where we are in society, where we are going to want all of the friends we can get. As a convention of churches, that is who we are. We are together. At the SBC in June, I tweeted that the annual meeting is the one week of the year to me that it seems like everything is right in the world. You are there with God’s people, talking to them by the minute about missions, evangelism, and the local church. It is where we are. It is who we are. It is a sweet thing to be together in this task of training pastors, ministers, and evangelists for the church.

Of course, we have branded Midwestern Seminary as being a seminary for the Church. That is not just a brand statement. It is, we trust, a statement of our identity and will be increasingly so. One of the things I tell folks is that we exist best for the church when we are most in the church as a seminary. We are seeking to do all we can to hardwire this institution into local churches through partnerships, through internships, through talking to pastors on a daily basis as to how we best serve them. Not only is there not a great chasm, we pray there is no chasm, no distance, no daylight between what we are aspiring to do and what churches aspire us to do.

Dr. Akin:

I think you are exactly right. In fact, I have been saying for a number of years—and my heart resonates with yours 100 percent—the best theological education takes place in a partnership with a seminary and the local churches. There are some things that the seminary can do more easily than the local church. I would never say that we can replace the local church in any area. Theoretically, the local church could do all of the things that we do, including teaching Greek, Hebrew, ethics, philosophy, and so on. We are set up in such a way as to do that more easily than they are.

On the other hand, there are some things that we are not capable of doing in a seminary classroom that can only be learned in the laboratory—and if you like I will use a stronger metaphor—the furnace of the local church. We need to recognize that we do not need to try to do everything. We cannot do everything, but in partnership with the local church, we can provide a comprehensive, holistic, well-rounded preparation for ministry that really will set these men and women in good stead for serving our churches well.

I love what you are saying. We do a better job of teaching theology, biblical studies, and everything else if we are doing so with a vision for fulfilling the Great Commission and in deep connection with the life of the local church. You put that combination together, and you are going to produce some well-trained, well-informed, well-equipped ministers.

Dr. Allen:

Absolutely. That is a very accurate and helpful way of thinking of it and of putting it frankly.

Dr. Akin:

I think churches would like to be partnered with us. I think sometimes, we did—not intentionally—navigate toward an ivory tower mindset where we spoke down to them. We spoke at them when we should have been in conversation all along. The fact of the matter is that they are in the trenches. Therefore, they see things that we do not see, and when they are asking for us to assist them in those areas, rather than push back, we ought to be quick to respond because they are out there with real people in real life, doing real ministry. If we are not meeting their needs to be equipped to do that, we forfeit our right to exist, Jason.

Dr. Allen:

I totally agree, Danny. Thank you. That is very well put. Someone said to me recently, “Seminary presidents, you guys never really criticize each other publicly.” And they said it with a whiff of us having some secret handshake or agreement. I laughed and said, “You are right. I have been at this a little over a year, and no one has ever said to me, ‘Whatever you do, do not criticize other seminary presidents.’ There is no agreement. There is no secret covenant. There is no political calculation we have made collectively. It is just the fact that as I have gotten to know these five men, known their hearts and minds, they are men that I deeply respect.”

I knew all five seminary presidents to a greater or lesser degree before taking the job but have gotten to know in a very personal way that these are men who love their wives and love their families. These are men who resolve to keep trust with the SBC, who are doing their very best under God to serve the churches and their seminaries. Not only do I endorse that, my heart overflows in light of that. I say this not merely publicly; I say it privately to people as well. I say it to prospective students on nearly a daily basis that come through here and say, “I am considering Southern. I am considering Southwestern.” I say, “Here is who we are; here is what I think we do well. Here is where we are going and what I am seeking to build, but I find joy and assurance in you going to any of the six Southern Baptist seminaries.” I cannot say that about every seminary in America. As a matter of fact, I cannot say that about many seminaries in America. I can say that about the SBC seminaries, and I can say that about a few others as well. I say, “I can find joy in that. I really can.”

You have six seminaries with different cultures, different leadership, different ministry emphases, different strengths and weaknesses, but when you look at the overall operation we can find joy in it. I know you share the same assessment, but would you elaborate on that?

Dr. Akin:

Absolutely. I tell folks when they visit Southeastern, “When it comes to our six seminaries, you are in a win, win, win, win, win, win situation. If you come here, I think you will come to a great school. If you go to Midwestern, or Southwestern, or New Orleans, or Golden Gate, you are going to go to a great school.”

You are right, we do not criticize each other publicly because we love each other; we support each other; and we want each other to succeed and do well. We have healthy conversations behind the scenes like any good brothers will. Every time we come out of our meetings—you know this very well—we come out with one voice, one heart, and one mind standing together. We have covenanted to be each other’s cheerleader. We have covenanted to be each other’s prayer partner, and I rejoice when I see Midwestern succeeding.

There are enough students to train for all six of us and then some. There are enough lost people to reach that all six of us can be full up with our responsibilities until the day that we pass off the scene. So, rather than being adversaries, which makes no sense for brothers in Christ, even to be in competition with one another—yes, maybe a little friendly competition—but again, we each rejoice with one another. That is because we are devoted to a common mission, we are convicted about a common core of theological beliefs. It is easy for us to come together and work in that kind of partnership. It is a joy and a delight.

Dr. Allen:

Absolutely. That is very well put. When you think about our role to serve the churches, and all of us—I knew this from serving at Southern, my previous location of service, and now here in a more acute way—we are entirely dependent on the churches to send us students. They do not owe that to us. They do not owe us students or money. We have the responsibility day-to-day to prove that we are a worthwhile investment and to prove that we are faithful to train the students they would send us.

As I say that, I also know we are not only dependent on the quantity of students they send, but as to the relative maturity of the students they send. Some people think that we can produce diamonds if they merely ship coal this direction. I say to people, “Never overestimate the power of a seminary. Do not underestimate it either. Great things can happen, and profound things can happen, for better or worse.” Make sure you have healthy schools because they will impact students, but we are not magicians. We are presidents. My professors are not magicians either. They are professors.

We are intentional about discipling, training, and teaching, but we need our churches to do their very best for the kingdom by investing in these students, discipling them from childhood through adolescence so that they show up here with elementary tools to begin this road of ministry. As a footnote to that statement, we acknowledge that so many are saved in college, so many are coming from broken homes, so many are coming from churches that are at relative degrees of health, so it really is so important that we receive this stewardship to do our very best to train them. I just want to state publicly as I do privately all the time—we are not magicians. We are dependent upon our churches to send us students who are poised for ministry success.

I want to especially bring that to bear in one reality. I was asked in a public setting by a student a while back, “What is the most important book I read before I come to seminary?” I said, “The Bible.” I think they thought that was a Sunday school answer. They said, “Yes, I read my Bible, but beyond the Bible what is the most important book I read.” I’ll say it again, “The Bible.” I do not merely mean that for the spiritual benefit, though I mean it for that. I mean it at every level because that is the one book that, if you are going to come to this seminary, your theological education will intersect with every day. You are going to be called to preach the Bible, to teach the Bible, to counsel the Bible, to bring the Word of God to bear on God’s people, which is the fundamental responsibility of the minister. You need to learn it, know it, and it needs to be a lifelong discipline. But nothing will more prepare your heart for the Christian life, your mind for theological education, and will kindle afresh your call to ministry than being in God’s Word day by day.

Dr. Akin:

I agree. What you said earlier, I think I can synopse it in a very simple statement. It is not our assignment to fix people. It is our assignment to train people. If we get broken people here, we will do our best to try to fix them, but every now and then, especially on the college level, we get students whose parents have forced to come here as a last resort, trying to get them fixed by us when they have been broken for the duration of their lives because of whatever took place in their family life. I try to help these families understand that we are not really set up or equipped to fix your child. We are set up to train them and prepare them for ministry, but if they need to be fixed, they probably need to be in a different context because that is not what a seminary is called to do and that is not what a seminary is called to be. We will try. We will give it our best shot, but you are right.

We really need to have people coming to us who sense that calling, who have the conviction, “This is what God is calling me to do with my life, and woe to me if I do not do this.” Thereby, they are in the mindset and the orientation for us to do something good with them. If they come broken, what I have experienced, unfortunately, Jason, is that most of the time they do not survive. Most of the time they become a disciplinary problem and, in short order, they usually wind up going back home embittered and perhaps worse off than when they got here.

Churches need to help us there. I am amazed sometimes at the endorsement forms we get, when a certain student turns out in a certain way, and I contact the church and the word I get is, “Well, we wanted to give them a chance.” No, no, no. You should have told the truth. You should have been completely up front and above board so that we knew what we were getting. If we did let them in, we did so knowing we needed to give them additional attention. We needed to give them a special eye. You could have helped us help them better if you had been completely truthful and trustworthy with us.

So, we really do have a trust with the churches. Sometimes, as I tell folks, the students who come to us that are kind of messed up, you got them messed up. You sent them that way. We are trying to do our best now to correct the mess that took place prior to them getting here. You put us in an awkward position, especially when you did not tell us in advance this is what was headed our way. This trust runs both ways, but it is a good trust and one that is most of the time honored. We are talking about the exceptions that become the squeaky wheels and become something that requires an inordinate amount of time and attention. I can say, having been involved in this now for 22 years, those are the exception rather than the norm.

Dr. Allen:

That is good and very helpful. I would say, as a pastor, I cannot preach a powerful enough sermon in 40 minutes to undo or fix a week’s worth of bad parenting. As a seminary president, I say I cannot, in a few semesters, fix a lifetime of bad parenting. You are right, we are called to train ministers and you always have someone who shows up trying to find themselves, or someone who shows up in a less-than-ideal scenario, and you just have to work through that. Thankfully, that is a very small percentage of people.

I want to draw our conversation to a close with a couple of things. I want to ask a couple of personal questions. One related to me, and one related to you. I think it will be fun to reflect upon this for a few moments.

You have been at Southeastern for roughly 10 years. What have you learned about theological education? By that, I mean, you knew it as well as anyone. You served at Southeastern with Paige Patterson, the maestro of theological education. You served at Southern Seminary with Al Mohler in key roles, as well at Southeastern and Southern seminary in a most key role with another maestro in theological education. Before that you were at Criswell College. So, if anyone was prepared to do this, you were. Tell us something that you have learned in the past 10 years that will be especially germane and informative to those who will be listening today.

Dr. Akin:

I would say two things, Jason. One, you have to be vigilant to maintain theological integrity. It does not just happen by accident. You must take with seriousness your confessions of faith. You must have a faculty that knows they are to teach in accordance with, and not contrary to [the Baptist Faith and Message 2000], without mental reservation or hesitation. I love that classical confessional language. You beat that drum over, and over, and over, and over. Just like you beat the drum for the Great Commission, you beat the drum for doctrinal integrity, and you do not relax that one bit because you never drift to the theological right; you always drift to the theological left.

Secondly, I would say we need to strive to have balance in our theology and know what hills are worth dying on and what hills are not. I fear sometimes that we raise to a level-one tier certain issues that belong on the second or third tier. I will fight you tooth and nail over the historical, bodily return of Christ— to the death. I am not going to fight you over whether you are premillennial, postmillennial, or amillennial. I happen to be premillennial, but I have colleagues who take different millennial positions. I am not going to fight you whether you are pre-tribulation, post-tribulation, mid-tribulation, partial rapture, or pre-rapture. I am pre-tribulation, but I believe that there is room for disagreement on the time of the rapture, just not the truth of the rapture.

We need to know where the stakes need to be driven down, and I think there is a health to having theological balance. I will give you one example. This is the classic one: divine sovereignty and human responsibility. Which are you to believe? Yes. You are to believe them both. I say over and over and over to my students, “I believe God is sovereign in predestining and electing people to be saved, but he does so in such a way as to not violate our free will and responsibility to believe the gospel.” How does he do that? I do not know. That is why he is God, and I am not. I just know this: anything that weakens the sovereignty of God is unbiblical and theologically dangerous. Anything that weakens the responsibility of man to repent and believe the gospel is unbiblical and theologically dangerous. So, we need to avoid those kinds of extremes and maintain a good, strong, healthy balance of our view of Scripture.

Dr. Allen:

That is good. That is very helpful. Thank you for sharing that. I have one other question. I put you on the spot personally, and I am going to put you on the spot again personally. Here is a boomerang question back to me. When you think about our roles—in a sense you have been in theological education your whole adult life. Then you have me. I have been at it a little over a year. You have been at it 10 years. Give me some wise words. Words that our listeners would find of interest, but to me. How would you encourage me as a young seminary president? What would you encourage me to keep on the forefront of my mind as I lead Midwestern Seminary?

Dr. Akin:

Stay close to Christ. Love well your wife and your kids, and love well the people that God places under your care. If your faculty and staff believe that you love them and care about them—in other words, my model, right or wrong, Jason, is that we are called to be pastors of the seminary that we lead—they will love you back. They will trust you when you have to make hard decisions. They will follow you because they know, “He is in my corner, and he will go the extra mile for me. If he can serve me, he will.” When you build that kind of rapport with those people that work underneath you, they will have such trust in you and such respect for you. They will be a delight. You will not have to worry too often about getting shot in the back of the head.

Dr. Allen:

Right. Well, let’s hope we do not have to worry very often about that literally. This has been a fun conversation. It has been a helpful one. Again, just to restate what I said at the beginning, we are blessed men. We serve the finest people on the planet—Southern Baptists. We are not perfect. We are not perfect at all, but by-and-large, you walk into any gathering of Southern Baptists anywhere—whether it is in Mississippi, Montana, Missouri, India, Kenya—you tend to find people who love Jesus, who love the Bible, who love the Great Commission, and who love one another.

Dr. Akin:

They are family.

Dr. Allen:

They are and it is. It is an incredible breed of people, and it is just a real honor to get to serve them. Thank you so much for the time here. I love you and pray for you. May God bless Southeastern in every way, and we pray he blesses Midwestern as well.

 

*Recorded 23 October, 2013 in the Spurgeon Room



A Conversation with John MacArthur about Preaching

Audio: A Conversation with John MacArthur about Preaching

Transcript:

Dr. Allen:

Dr. MacArthur, it is a joy to host you here in the Spurgeon Room on the campus of Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary. We are in the Spurgeon Room, surrounded by Spurgeon’s library, desk, and books on preaching. So, it is so fitting and appropriate to talk to you, who in my estimation and in the estimation of many others have proven to be our generation’s Spurgeon—a man with a massive ministry that impacts so many people in so many different conduits, but at the very center of that, like Spurgeon, is the pulpit ministry.

I want to talk preaching with you today. Let me begin by asking you, as you think of yourself—your fundamental identity beyond husband and father—is it safe to assume that you think of yourself first and foremost as a preacher or pastor?

Dr. MacArthur:

Oh, absolutely. Even as I think of myself as a pastor, I think of myself as a preacher. All that I really have to offer as a pastor is my preaching. Anybody else can offer anything else. Anybody else can come alongside, sympathize, care for, come up with good ideas, and offer some leadership. Lay people can do that. In fact, hopefully we are training people to do that so that we can multiply ministry.

I am, above all things, a preacher. I could give up everything tomorrow. I could walk away from radio. I really do not care. If the Lord wants me to do that, that’s fine. I do not need to write another book. I do not need to be a president of an institution. I do not need any of that, but I cannot live if I do not preach.

It is not that I am driven by the crowd to do that. It is not external. I am driven internally to do that. This is a calling upon my life. It is almost an inexplicable drive within me. It is work to preach, as you well know. It is work to prepare, but I do it, and I do it with a certain joy. Sometimes I stand up, even now, after all these years, and I walk around because I am overwhelmed by what I have just discovered or seen. It is an internal drive that is the heart of a calling. It is not because I can do it. It is not because I can communicate, have skill at communication, or because people like to listen to me. It is internal.

Sometimes people say, “Well, you came to our church, and we just have a little church and it is so nice of you to come.” That is irrelevant to me. It is not about them. It is about me. It is about this passion internally to deliver the Word of God. That is what drives me. That is who I am. Every book I have ever written started as a sermon. Every commentary I have ever written started as a sermon. In fact, I have other jobs, and what I do is meet with people and preach at them.

Dr. Allen:

That is good, and of course, it is so Pauline: “If any man aspires to the office of the overseer.” It is the burden of the prophet, the fire in their bones, overflowing into the heart, and you cannot envision yourself doing anything else, nor can a generation of ministers, pastors, and church members who have been affected by your ministry.

When we think of preaching specifically—define, in your own words—expository preaching. What is it?

Dr. MacArthur:

Maybe we could just make a contrast. Sometimes you hear people say, “Expose the text.” That is not the verb. The verb is not “expose.” That is one thing. The verb is “exposit.” That is a specific verb, and what it means is to explain. An exposition is an explanation. That is as simple as I can make it. Explain the meaning of Scripture.

Now, having said that, the society in which you live—the culture and whatever is intuitive to you—has no bearing on that explanation. What is going on around you or what is going on inside of you has no bearing on that explanation. The only thing that has bearing on that explanation is the context in which that explanation was founded or grounded. So, we have to talk about authorial intent. What was the intent of the divine author and the human instrument when that was written down? It is so important for people to understand that true biblical exposition must take the listener back to the original context.

So, instead of saying we have to bring the Bible into modern times, that is exactly the opposite of what we need to do. We need to take the modern hearer into Bible times. I think the adventure for us at Grace Church is that we have lived in the Bible. Our people have dirt on their feet from walking the dusty roads with Jesus. They live in the New Testament world. They know the Pharisees. They feel the ethos of Jesus in a crowd in a village because they have lived that, because we have painted that picture for them. They know what Isaiah was going through. They understand what it meant for Jeremiah to be thrown into a pit.

The great excitement of biblical exposition is taking people on a historical journey. I know people today want to go forward into fantasy land, which is counterproductive. What we do is take them back into real biblical history and let the Bible come alive. That is the heart of biblical exposition. You cannot know what it meant unless you recreate the setting: geographically, socially, historically, linguistically, and all of those things.

I have to say that because there are people who read a verse and bounce off of it, and read another verse and bounce off of it, and read another verse and bounce off of it. That is not Bible exposition. You may take a simple truth from Scripture and expound on it or talk about it for a little bit, but exposition works in a unique way.

Let me explain it this way, if I have explained the Bible well enough, and accomplished the setup well enough, I can read the verse and they will understand the meaning. Just creating the context and reading the verse, boom, it comes to life. It is as simple as Jesus saying, “I am the light of the world.” You can take, “I am the light of the world” in John 8 and say, “Yeah, he is the light of the world. The world is dark, and needs his light,” but what was going on there? Well, he was in the part of the temple where the great candelabra had been extinguished because the feast was over. This was the first day that the light was out, and he stands up and says, “I am the light of the world, I never go out.” Wow! Now you have put him there. That is how you really explain the meaning of Scripture. That is what Bible exposition is.

Dr. Allen:

That is so well said. I read an article a number of years ago by a gentleman who was referencing and describing different influential speakers. When he came to John MacArthur, he said the “secret sauce”—that is my phrase, not his—of your preaching was that you preach with unsurpassed confidence. He meant that as more of a clinical assessment, and of course, I know what he missed, and want you to comment on. You are a confident preacher, but your confidence is not something that you conjure up within yourself. You are confident because you preach the Scripture. So, talk about what confidence is in preaching, and how that is derived.

Dr. MacArthur:

I do not have confidence as some mechanism. I have confidence out of a conviction. I know you say there might be some passages you are debating about what the actual interpretation is. You might go two or three ways. It could mean this; it could mean that. Once I make up my mind on what I think the best interpretation is—the best rendering of a given passage—I will preach that with confidence. I will preach that with conviction.

Sometimes that conviction may not be as strong. If I am preaching on the death of Christ as the sufficient sacrifice to God, I can preach that with every ounce of conviction. If I have a certain view of the baptism for the dead in I Corinthians 14, which could have 25 interpretations, the level of my conviction might vary.

When it comes to the decision I make, that this is what I think is the best interpretation, then I preach it and let it go. I can do that, and I think I can do it safely because whatever that conclusion is, even on a difficult passage, it is within the framework of acceptable biblical interpretation and theology. So I do not go out of bounds.

This is why—and you would know this, Dr. Allen, here at the seminary—seminaries have to teach systematic theology, because you can teach Bible exposition, and you must, but you need systematic theology because so much of preaching and so much of ministry is extemporaneous. If you do not know the boundaries of theology, then in those extemporaneous moments—in the freedoms of ministry—you go out of bounds. You are not going to do that if your theology is sound. 

Dr. Allen:

Right. It is the scaffolding that holds it together.

Dr. MacArthur:

Not only that, but it is the borders; it is the fences you do not go beyond. You are not going to have a student say something completely out of bounds because they are contained by that sound, historic theology that has been passed down and tested, tried, and proven.

Dr. Allen:

Take us into the study for a moment, preparing a sermon. Give us an overview of how you did it 40 years ago and how you do it today. I know there are great similarities. Just take us into the study. How do you get from the shop preparing it to the showroom presenting it?

Dr. MacArthur:

First is isolation. I have a place at home, a little desk against the window where I can look out and see the trees and the green grass. I have a chair that goes forward and back; it goes forward so I can read and it goes back so I can think. I get an 8 ½ x 14 legal pad, and I start by reading the passage.

Now remember, I am in a book, so I am in a context. I take that passage—let’s say it is six verses—and I write them down with some space in between on maybe six sheets, and I start thinking about the passage: its construction and its context. I go back to the original Greek and look at that. I go to lexicons and make sure I know what it says. That is the first thing: “What does it say?” Then, I start thinking about what it means, and I start writing that and meditating on that. Then I get cross references because I think the Bible explains itself best and is consistent. Analogia Scriptura was a Reformation conviction: the Bible is analogous to itself. I write all of that down.

Then, I start lining up commentaries. There is a great quote from Spurgeon in which he says he wants those people who think the Holy Spirit is speaking to them to remember that the Holy Spirit has illuminated many, many in the past. I know that I am dependent upon the illumination of faithful men of the past. That is why I read commentaries and I am looking for every possible insight and understanding, every possible expansion of the implication of a concept or a doctrine or whatever, and I just take all kinds of notes on that.

So, I am going back over those same sheets from commentaries. I pick up a theological theme, find books on theology, fill that up. I am never thinking outside of the Bible. I am never thinking about illustrations or anything like that at that point. I am just piling on the things that help me to fully understand the text. I do not think about a sermon. I am not trying to make a sermon. I am just trying to master the text and what it means.

When I am done with that, I know the point and I know the sub points. I put an outline on top of it, and then I write an introduction and conclusion. Now I have a rough draft. I meditate on that and think on that. I write some more notes, do some crafting of how that might work, and I write it by hand in a final form of, say, eight half-sheets. Now it is in me, and it is on the page. That is what I would take into the pulpit.

That is a process that can take me anywhere from, well, it used to take me 15–20 hours. It is probably more like 8–12 hours now, or 8–10, and it is still the same process. You say, “Well, you have been doing it so long, why does it still take you a long time?” If no other reason, because everything I have ever said they have recorded. So, whatever I need to say, I need to say in a different way. 

Dr. Allen:

Right. That is very helpful. Now, when you think about expository preaching and the length of a passage under consideration—and of course, in your ministry you are typically preaching through larger passages than in the later years—you have ebbed and flowed. You went through Mark more briskly than some of the other Gospels.

Talk about faithfulness to expository preaching through the text, and how you marry that to a specific passage of Scripture. So, you think about a Martyn Lloyd Jones, who was so given to exhausting a verse of its meaning, and you contrast that with a guy like Mark Dever, who is faithful to Scripture, but typically mows through it at a broader length. How do you balance that?

Dr. MacArthur:

This is my own conviction. It took me 43 years to preach through the New Testament. That was too fast. I left too much out. I am not going to pass that way again. I remember an early American preacher who preached for 42 years in his church and died in Isaiah 8. He started in Isaiah 1 and 42 years later died in Isaiah 8. So, that would be the extreme—Barnhouse extreme on Romans, or Lloyd Jones on something.

Now, I think you can go into all of the world and preach everything off of a text if you are not careful, but I think it is so profound and so rich that people need more than an overview. It is not the concepts that are inspired. It is the words that are inspired. You are making that decision every week. How far do I go? How much do I say? Maybe one of the hardest things about preaching is deciding what to leave out.

Here is how that works—after I have gotten all of that material together, then I decide what to make the sermon, and I leave things off those final notes. I get into the pulpit, and they have a way of coming back. I may determine to leave things out that end up being in, and sometimes they are better than what I had planned to be in.

I am going back through the Gospel of John right now, after preaching and writing a commentary, and I looked at my early notes and I cannot use them at all. I looked at my commentary and said, “Ah, I would like to write that again.” I am going through John with completely fresh insight, and it is richer than it has ever been. It is so exhaustive that I lobby for the in-depth approach, particularly if you are in a church. If you are an itinerant guy, and you are not going to have an opportunity to do that, fine, give people overviews. I remember going to Calvary Chapel one Sunday night, and Chuck Smith preached. He was going through Matthew, and he preached from Matthew 24–28. Not verses; chapters. I thought there might be a little in there that got missed. 

Dr. Allen:

Right, and if you are going to do an overview, that is not the easiest passage to overview.

Dr. MacArthur:

I have always felt like there is such profound richness. I go back to Job and the book of Proverbs, where it says, “Like mining, dig down in the earth, go deep, and uncover this truth.” So I may belabor the point a little bit, but I do think, having said that, it is important also to say that you cannot just wander through, mining out loosely connected stuff. I think every sermon has to be an entity in itself, a unit in itself. That is what the genius of Spurgeon was. There was a beginning, and an end, and a middle, and a main point. And it was memorable and captivating. I think you can do that with exposition. You want to avoid a commentary approach. You want to read commentaries, but you want to avoid just commenting on the Bible. You want to pull out of that passage one great, impactful, memorable, convicting, powerful message.

Dr. Allen:

And drive it home. That is good. That is so helpful. So, here we are, John MacArthur, the preacher at Grace Community Church, after all of these years preaching. Obviously, folks know of you and you will be remembered as a preacher. Is there any particular aspect of your preaching or observation about your preaching—if you could choose to be remembered by—that you would like to be remembered?
Dr. MacArthur:

That is a very good question. I do not want to evaluate my preaching, but in answering that question, this is what I hear, “You are very clear, and you are simple to understand.” Maybe one of the most interesting comments I have ever received was from some folks who work in missions. They said, “We find your preaching most accessible to people for whom English is their second language.” How interesting. It is easily translatable into any language. I think simple and clear is really, really important. At the end of the day, this is what we are all trying to do—get it down so that it comes across. That would be in terms of style.

In terms of content, what I hear is that the best of my preaching—the most telling of my preaching—is from the four Gospels. My focus on Christ is the richest work that I have done. That thrills me and that is because he is so compelling. If you give me an opportunity, I would rather preach Christ than anything. I would rather preach out of the Gospels than anywhere.

Dr. Allen:

That is so Spurgeon-esque, as we are here thinking of Spurgeon and celebrating his legacy.

Dr. MacArthur, this has been very insightful, and I trust very helpful. You have the three different components of a truly historic preacher: A) The ability to do it. You do it. B) The ability to teach it and transfer it, but then C) a lifetime, a faithfulness, that buttresses it. Thank you for all three of those things.

Dr. MacArthur:

That is the goodness of the Lord.

Dr. Allen:

Thank you. This has been an enjoyable conversation. Thank you for your ministry to us.

Dr. MacArthur:

Thank you.

 



A Conversation with John MacArthur about Strange Fire

Audio: A Conversation with John MacArthur about Strange Fire

Transcript:

Dr. Allen:

Dr. MacArthur, it is a joy to host you in the Spurgeon Room on the campus of Midwestern Seminary in the President’s home. We are delighted to have you here for the Spurgeon Lectures, and you have already encouraged us through your preaching ministry this morning. I want to hop right into a conversation that is hot and that is on your mind, obviously, in recent weeks. You hosted—just a matter of days ago—the Strange Fire Conference at Grace Community Church. I want to revisit that and talk through it some. I would love to follow up on different aspects of that conference. I will make a confession on the front end of the conversation: I was genuinely surprised—maybe even shocked—by the level of interest that it generated. I was shocked because I have followed your ministry for a number of years, and you have been speaking about this issue to a greater or lesser degree for more than 40 years. So, I would love to know—now that we are a few days removed from the conference—were you surprised by the interest and even the intensity that the conference itself generated?

Dr. MacArthur:

I think to some degree we were surprised. The first day there were 127 nations live streaming that event, and there were 25,000 separate connects. We do not know how many people were behind that. That was the first day, and it got greater the second day and greater the third day. I do not know that I really expected that, but I did expect a bigger response than books I have written in the past, or emphases I’ve made on this in the past simply because the Reformed non-cessationists or the Reformed continuationists made space in the broad realm of Evangelicalism for the elements of the Charismatic Movement.

If you say prophecy continues, miracles continue, tongues continue, signs and wonders are still valid, then you have opened up a world of possibility. So, what has happened is, when I wrote Charismatic Chaos or the book called The Charismatics or addressed this in the past, it was contained. It was contained originally within classical Pentecostalism. Then it spread a little bit into the Second Wave, which is when the charismatic experience infiltrated the Roman Catholic Church and the mainline denominations. It was still outside Evangelicalism.

With the arrival of people like Wayne Grudem, who really did open the door when he did his dissertation on prophecy and talked about prophecy still existing as fallible prophecy. Then it was picked up by D. A. Carson, and it was picked up by John Piper and Sam Storms and other people like that. These are respected people that are really honored by all of us on some fronts. So, it has made space in Evangelicalism for this particular view. Now when you confront this view, you are not just targeting heterodox groups. You are hitting orthodox groups.

Dr. Allen:

Right.

Dr. MacArthur:

So, it is simply the breadth of the tolerance of that which created the response. There was no negative response particularly coming from classic Pentecostals, like the Four Square Assemblies. Most of the heat coming at us was coming from Evangelical continuationists.

Dr. Allen:

When you think about the movement as a whole—the Charismatic Movement, and the different strains of it—what particular strain, or strains, animates you the most about the harm they are doing to the church?

Dr. MacArthur:

That is a very good question. I think the more bizarre the aberration, the more disturbing it is.

I go back to where I was when I first wrote on this many, many years ago. I just find the possibility of continuing revelation very disturbing. I do not care what form it is in. You can say, “Well, it is not equal to Scripture; it could be fallible.” I just see that as a major problem. What you are now telling me—whether it is somebody listening for the voice of God; whether it is somebody writing a book, like Sarah Young, in which she is talking as if she is Jesus in the first person speaking to me—whatever form you are now adding to Scripture, to me it is very disturbing.

That, I think is the foundational issue. So, if you allow for anything beyond Scripture, then you have to ask, “By what criteria do we judge that this is truly the voice of God?” If there are not objective, fixed, divinely-revealed criteria for that, you cannot control the movement.

Dr. Allen:

Right. Absolutely. It calls into question, and really undermines, the whole logic of 2 Timothy 3:16–17, that Scripture has been given so that the man of God may be thoroughly equipped, adequate for every good work.

Dr. MacArthur:

So, am I inadequate? From the perspective of the Charismatics, they would see me as inadequate because they think I do not have the baptism of the Holy Spirit, the classical one. In other words, if they are the old-line Pentecostals, they say speaking in tongues is the evidence of the baptism of the Spirit, and if I haven’t done it, then I do not have it.

From the continuationists’ viewpoint, I am not hearing God speak, so I am somehow locked in time to the past, and if I do not hear the voice of God, I am missing out on something.

In any case, yes, it stuffs me in the corner, apart from whatever the Holy Spirit may be doing or saying in the moment.

Dr. Allen:

The three books you have written, especially dealing with this issue, are The Charismatics—I guess that was in the mid 1970s—Charismatic Chaos, in the early 1990s—and now Strange Fire. How are those books different, or is Strange Fire in essence a reissuing of Charismatic Chaos?

Dr. MacArthur:

The Charismatics and Charismatic Chaos were somewhat similar. Strange Fire is completely different. The movement has demanded this. The closing chapter in Strange Fire is entitled, “An Open Letter to My Continuationists Friends,” and it addresses them. The opening chapters look at the current state of the movement.

It is far worse now than it was then in terms of the extreme kinds of behaviors, I think. You have to change the illustrations, but I think it has to be evaluated on a completely fresh and new basis. I think there are much more tightly, carefully argued sections on prophecy, tongues, healing, and the legitimacy of these gifts than what they were.

The historical argument is there, but maybe the major difference in the book—or one component that people would benefit from—Is the actual history of the movement. Where does it come from? You know the fruit by the root. The chapter on the history alone is frightening.

Then, the second chapter, that we have not done anything with in the past, is on the apostles. If the apostles ceased—If it is true that there are no more apostles or that there were 12 minus Judas, plus Mathias and Paul—then there is a dramatic change in the church and the gifting to the church. Since apostles are called “gifts” in Ephesians 4, if there are no apostles, then we know some gifts have ceased.

Dr. Allen:

Right.

Dr. MacArthur:

If the apostles ceased, then there is a cessation. If the apostles cease, then the signs and wonders of an apostle cease—so the whole argument of apostleship is important.

The other argument in this book—that I think is really critical—is that the continuationists are saying that prophecy exists, but it is not infallible. Then, it is not what biblical prophecy is. Tongues exists, but it is not language. Then, it is not what biblical tongues were. Healings exist, but they are not like the healings of Jesus. If that is true, then you are essentially a de facto cessationist because you just said these are not that. So what are they? You are a cessationist who has invented something that is not in the New Testament.

There is no such thing in the Bible as fallible prophecy from God. There is no such thing as gibberish, and there is no such thing as moderate, indiscernible healing. So whatever it is that you are calling prophecy, healing, and tongues is not that. What I am trying to do with these guys is say, “You cannot call yourself a continuationist, because by your own admission, it is not the same. So, what is it, and why are you inventing it?”

Dr. Allen:

More of a “hypothetical continuationist.”

Dr. MacArthur:

Yes. Why are you doing this? Who are you conceding this to? Do you feel it is necessary for you to have some supernatural, mystical phenomenon to confirm your faith? Are you deferring to your wife, who was raised in the Charismatic Movement or are you trying to find space in the big Evangelical picture, so you are giving this concession? I just do not understand why you would invent things—call them biblical names—when you know they are not the biblical reality.

That is the direction the book goes. Just a quick footnote to that: The kickback has been, “Oh, you are painting with a broad brush,” or “You have not acknowledged that there are good things that happen in the movement.” So far, we have not seen anything that argues the biblical points. Eventually, the book Strange Fire, the conference, and what was said there is going to have to be debated on the grounds of biblical interpretation. That is where we would like to force the issue.

Dr. Allen:

So, since you referenced the conference and some of the buzz and criticism that has come from it—just to ask a very direct question—Is there any edge you left sharp that you wish you would have rounded or anything you left unsaid, that in hindsight you wish you would have said, or any second guessing? Obviously, I know you are established theologically. I do not mean in that sense, but is there anything about it that, if you could redo it, you would do differently or not include?

Dr. MacArthur:

That is a really good question. You know as a preacher, you say what is in your notes, and then you say what comes into your head, right?

Dr. Allen:

Right.

Dr. MacArthur:

So, if you could go back to almost any sermon you preached and said it again another way, you would do that. Our dear, beloved Charles Spurgeon: people read his sermons, and most people do not realize that is not what he preached. That is, in some cases, hardly close to what he preached because he got those dictation notes from the people who took his notes. He got that stuff on Monday, and I have actual copies hanging in my office at home of his editing himself off of those transcripts.

So, sure, we would all do that. Here was the approach; this was a very serious issue. Misrepresenting the Holy Spirit, there is nothing more serious than that. Accusing the Holy Spirit of things that he would not have anything to do with is a serious issue. In all honesty, we wanted to push this thing to the limit. This was landing at the beach. This was D-Day.

Dr. Allen:

Right.

Dr. MacArthur:

We came with everything we had. Having done that, we wanted to see the response. Where is it going to come from? I told the guys it is going to come in two ways. They are going to say, “You are lumping us all together,” and they are going to say, “You have not affirmed the good things.”

So at that point we will blunt that point a bit and come back and say, “Look, I said this many times, so did everybody else.” There are Christians in the movement who are faithful pastors that love the Bible and are trying to do the best they can. There are moderate aspects of that movement, and there are extreme.

Dr. Allen:

Sure.

Dr. MacArthur:

They are all connected. So, the brush can be broad, but we do need to recognize that there are differences, and we do need to express gratitude for those who have taught the gospel and preached the gospel. As a result, people have been converted.

Now, as we establish where we are, we will begin to speak in that fashion. Then, we still have to get to the biblical argument.

Dr. Allen:

Sure.

Dr. MacArthur:

In a conversation I had with one of the leading continuationists, he said, “Well, what I need to do then is write a book in response.”

I said, “Exactly.”

Dr. Allen:

Very good. In your mind, do you have a working distinction between Charismatics and continuationists? Or do you see that as one category of terms that can be used interchangeably?

Dr. MacArthur:

I would just listen to what they call themselves. I do not know that I would openly call someone a Charismatic who does not take that label, and they are sort of wobbling on that. There are some who did call themselves Charismatics. We quote one in the book who is now wanting to call himself a continuationist because he wants to distance himself from all that [the word charismatic] means. I really do not mind the labels, but I do not want to throw labels around. “Charismatic,” I think, is a good term because it is a term that refers to those who think the gifts of grace are still fully operational. So, it is not a pejorative in any sense—and unless they disdain that term, which I have not heard anybody do that—I think you can call people Charismatics.

I think even the classics, who would be known as Pentecostals, would call themselves Charismatics in the sense that they are open to the continuation of the gifts.

Dr. Allen:

When you think about the global Charismatic movement, estimates of their number is about 500 million, so an incredible mass of people. They are nearly half the size of the Roman Catholic Church. And people, if they are on the American side of the conversation and that circle is the Evangelical side of the conversation, they tend to think of the nutty people, the fringe, as being the red herring. They think of the norm being the John Pipers, the Wayne Grudems, the Martyn Lloyd Joneses. If you do a global assessment, you realize, “No, really John Piper and Wayne Grudem are more the red herrings.”

Dr. MacArthur:

Yes, they are the fringe. All you have to do is turn on any Charismatic network. Just pick any one. You will see the same panoply of false teachers, prosperity gospel preachers, healers, health and wealth guys, and you will hear the same claims to healing. Somebody who wants to present himself as a news anchor kind of image like Pat Robertson is saying things that are just as nutty as some far out healer in a tent.

So, it is everywhere. I do not know that they would all want to be put in the same package, but as I said before, once you say that the Holy Spirit is talking—and you do not have any static, fixed way to evaluate that, to define that, or to say yes or no to that—you really cannot control the thing.

We have to defer to the default position which is this: we know that John Piper, Wayne Grudem, and people like that are not crazy. They are not nutty. They are not going to fall into those kinds of patterns. What they need to do, of course, is rise up and condemn those kinds of aberrations, and I would like to see more of that.

Dr. Allen:

Thank you. You have been so faithful as a prophetic voice to the church for so many years—whether it was the Lordship Controversy or the issues of creationism, gender roles, or your concerns about the Charismatic movement as you have spoken to for decades. So, thank you for your consistency, your faithfulness, and for being an Ephesians 4:15 man—speaking the truth in love, even when it is difficult, even when you are challenging your friends and your brothers.

Dr. MacArthur:

Well, thank you. For me it is about the truth. I have no desire to harm friends or lose friends in the process, but I am propelled by the truth. I really think that my friends are too; and as long as we can keep that conversation going and speak the truth in love, it can be beneficial and hopefully we can find our way to the unity that comes around the truth. As I said at the conference, it is better to be divided by the truth than united by error.

Dr. Allen:

That is right. Very well said. Well, thank you for revisiting Strange Fire with us, and for your book. Thank you for the gift of your book last night. I look forward to reading it in the days ahead.

Dr. MacArthur:

Thank you.



A Conversation with Danny Akin about Family, Faith, and Football

I still remember phrases I heard you say in seminary. Things like, “Gentlemen, I’d rather you get a C in my class and an A at home.” And things like, “You can have a great marriage without having a great ministry, but you cannot have a great ministry without having a great marriage.” Things like that just ring true. Read more



A Conversation with Frank Page about Suicide

Dr. Allen: Dr. Page, welcome to the Spurgeon Room. We are here on the campus of Midwestern Seminary in the President’s home and seated in the Spurgeon Room, named that because of the Spurgeon desk and the Spurgeon Library and different pieces on display here. We have the opportunity to host different guests here and talk about issues facing the church, the Christian life, culture, and so many other things. It is a real joy to get to talk to you today, and we are going to talk about a topic that is obviously at the very center of your heart, and a topic from a book that pierced me in the center of my heart, and that is your book entitled, Melissa with the subtitle, A Father’s Lessons from a Daughter’s Suicide. Allow me to begin this conversation with my own personal story here.

I had requested the PDF of this book from your office some time ago—just before it hit the bookstands. I received the email, and it was one of the longest days for me as president of Midwestern Seminary. It was long in a good way. It was a very full day. It started well before dawn, then I had meetings all afternoon. We had a major dinner where we hosted several hundred guests on campus that began at 7 p.m. and ended about 9:30 p.m., and then my wife and I hosted a couple for about a two-hour interview after that. I got back to my home office about 11 p.m., and I was just spent. I was worn out. I was ready to hit the bed at the end of a long day, which was the end of many longs days. I sat down at my desk, and I opened my email. I was in my suit, had my coat on, had done nothing to relax myself, and I opened that email. I read that manuscript over the course of about an hour and a half, or two hours without ever moving. I never got out of my suit. I just sat there, and I thought it would be one page and it was another, and it just arrested my attention. It is as though the book reached out of the computer monitor, grabbed my lapels, and drew me in. I cried reading it, and I am not a crier—my wife will tell you. I had the full range of emotions as I read that book, and I sent you an email that night after reading it, as you may recall. I want to unpack this book a little bit and the story behind it; and obviously we tread on holy ground, so to speak, given your story here and your family’s. I want to talk about the book and the story there, and I want to unpack it some for those who would read and those who would hear, and for you to be able to speak not only of the book, but from your heart, and convey the message that you would want to convey.

Dr. Page: Thank you, Dr. Allen. I deeply appreciate being here with you, and thank you for approaching this subject and allowing me to speak a little bit about it. I will probably say some things that I have not said in other places because it is scripted differently. Obviously, I am sometimes interviewed by radio stations, and they usually ask the same questions. The book was, I will admit, that I probably began it out of a self-centered reason. I thought it might be cathartic in healing. And indeed, that is true. But I quickly moved past the self-centered part and realized that people need help. I had friends encouraging me to write it for the right reasons, and indeed, that morphed into a dual desire.

Number one, to help people who have gone through suicide with a family, a friend, a church member, but then also, as the book is clear, it is also a tool to be used by those who are considering suicide. I will tell you that since it came out in electronic form on May 1and print on June 1, I am trying to keep a record of the number of people who have written me to say, “That book was written for me.” I just heard from someone in Texas two days ago who said, “I am suicidal, and that book has kept me from making that terrible decision.” Well, that is why I wrote it. It was not an easy book to write.

I am a crier, by the way. I cry probably every day over something. Even a silly commercial on TV, I will cry, but I am still somewhat private. So the book was a little difficult because I felt like I put my soul out on display. Then it was even more difficult because, while I wanted to be honest and transparent about my daughter, and about her struggles, and about our family’s struggles, I did not want to dishonor her memory. So that was very difficult to know that balance and to keep that balance in place; to not go off one way or the other. There are books written that perhaps are not very transparent, and then maybe there are those that just tell too much. I did not want to dishonor my baby’s memory. And so, I also will say that it is a well-written book. I am not a good writer, but Laurence Kimbrough was a co-writer. For example, I said one time, “Melissa was 98 pounds of pure fire.” He wrote it and said, “Melissa was 98 pounds, and rarely did she give an afternoon off to a single pound.” The way he wrote it was just great. My thoughts, my content, but his beautiful writing style helped make it a book that is very readable, engaging actually. Maybe that is partly the story as well as the writing style, but I wrote this to help people and it is touching many, many, many lives. I had a man this morning in the airport—an airline worker in the airport in Jackson, Miss., who said, “Rev. Page, I am getting the book that you wrote.” Well, I do not know how he knew about that book, but he did. He said, “I need it.” I do not know why; I didn’t have time to talk to him about it. Many people are reading it, and the whole purpose is I want people to know that help and hope are found in Christ. You can get help through a counselor and through a doctor. You should. But help and hope are ultimately found in Jesus Christ. And so, hope is what I wanted. And my wife, Dayne, said, “I just want hope to shine forth in that book.”

Dr. Allen: And it does. And boy, you read that as a father of five, and as a man who has been in ministry for about 15 years, and I have dealt with this more around the edges—never with someone in my immediate family, never with someone in my distant family, insofar as I know. And with church members, it was more around the edges of the church, not someone in the heart of the congregation. But you read that, and one of the things I appreciate is your directness with some of the struggles throughout life. It is not done in a way to in any way understate or overstate that. There is just a beauty in the simplicity of that which pierces the heart. One of the things that you touch on thematically in the book, and I would love for you to flesh out, is that clearly you had a unique relationship with her. She was the source of unique challenges, but there was a unique joy there. I know there are parents who have kids, and maybe there is a child who brings unique challenges and makes you want to pull your hair out, but at the same time there are unique joys associated with that. Would you please speak to that balance?

Dr. Page: Well, thank you, Dr. Allen. I will say every parent knows that. You know, it reminds me of the old story of the child psychologist who started his practice and he had four theories about raising children, although he had no children. Several years later, he had four children and no theories. You know, every child is unique. Certainly your precious children all have their own look and their own personality, and my three daughters all did. They are all strong-willed children, but they are all unique; and Melissa, she was unique. I used to tell her, “Melissa, nobody loves you like your daddy, but nobody knows you like your daddy.” And it would frustrate the fire out of her. She would say, “I hate that you always know when I’m not doing something right. You just somehow seem to know it.” I would say, “Yes, I do honey. And you need to remember that daddy knows.” But she was a unique person: fiery, probably, and you know in our milieu. We have some strong-willed friends; she was the most strong-willed person I have ever met—so strong-willed that her sweet mother could not handle her much of her life. I am too, and I admit that. I am a very dominant personality, and I have asked the Lord to help mellow that. I think he has some. I remember when we were expecting our first child. This was in the day that, where we were, there were no sonograms or anything. We did not know if we had a little boy or a girl, but I prayed for a girl, and I said, “If I have a boy, and he is like I was, my sweet wife will not be able to handle him.” But he gave us a female that had my male dominance in me. She was strong. I would say to her, “Honey, you can be meaner than a junkyard dog, or sweeter than the sweetest angel in the world.” So, she was a person of great contrasts, and many are. So the challenges were great, but I love her so deeply, and I miss her so unspeakably.

Dr. Allen: Take the book and compress it for two types of people. One is those who are dealing with either a potential suicide, or an actual suicide of a loved one. What word of encouragement would you give to them?

Dr. Page: For those who are dealing with someone who is considering suicide, I would encourage them to understand, first of all, that that person makes their own decisions. You have to be very careful. This is what happens, Jason, in a suicide situation where it has happened. In those who have survived, divorce rates go through the absolute roof. Suicides of survivors go up dramatically. Relationships crumble. Why? Because often we begin to blame. First of all, we blame God. Well, God didn’t cause that suicide. Second of all, we blame other people. “If you would have been a better mother, she wouldn’t have done that.” “If you would have been a better daddy… If you would have been a better whatever…” So, we are prone to do that. Understand that that person made their decision, and, unfortunately, made the wrong decision. So you first of all recognize reality. You can help, and you should. You need to do everything you can. Have I ever felt like a failure because my daughter committed suicide? Oh yeah. It still happens sometimes, but in my more cogent, sane moments I realize that I did the best I could at the time. I really did. I really did, but was I a prefect father? No. So, we have to realize reality. That person, that boy that girl, can decide what they want to decide. There are many voices people listen to other than the voice of mom and daddy and other than the voice of the Lord.

So, I say to those who have a family member who is considering it, realize that reality. At the same time, get them the help they need. There is help available in most places in most ways. Often times, when someone is calling us and threatening suicide—see that is the unique thing, Melissa never threatened suicide. Ever. We worried about her in many ways because of many affectations and many behavior changes, but she never threatened suicide. Many, in fact, most do. So, take those seriously. Get the help they need. But if it has happened in your life, again, minister. Let me just say this to those who are ministering to them: if you are in a church and someone has committed suicide, and I did have to deal with several in my ministry of 35 years, avoid trite platitudes. “Oh, they are in a better place.” Well, they may be, but that is probably not the time to say that. So, in your ministry to grieving people, be very careful to do what they need most, and what they need most is a ministry of presence. They need a friend. They need a family member who will love them and say, “I am going to be with you.” The day my daughter died, I mean immediately, the word got out and I had life-long friends who came and stayed with me. I don’t remember much of what they said. They didn’t say much, but they were there for me. They were with me, and when I lowered her in the grave, two of my life-long friends stood by me. Two of my male friends, one a retired general, one a car dealer I led to Christ back 20 years ago in Augusta, Ga., they stood with me. I do not think they said a word. They did not need to. So, we need to understand how to minister to those who are hurting. There are ways to do that, and there are ways not to do that. So, I have tried again to keep pointing to that in the book.

Someone asked me one time in a radio interview, “Well, you are always talking about Christ. What do you say to people outside of the faith?” Well, I say the same thing I do to people in the faith: that Christ is the only ultimate source. You can get help from friends; you can get help from books, whatever. Ultimately, only in Christ are you going to find the peace that God gives. Let me say this: why do I think God allowed Melissa to do what she did? Melissa was never at peace, and I think he let it happen so she could finally be at peace. I know she knew him. She struggled with that. I think he allowed it in his permissive will that she might finally rest.

Dr. Allen: I want you to unpack the other question I was contemplating, but thank you for opening up your heart there. One of the questions I have gotten throughout the years in ministry, with shocking frequency, because I do not understand theologically or biblically why one would think this or even have to ask this, but can a saved person commit suicide? And the answer of course is yes. But that seems to be a pervasive notion in the church today, that a saved person cannot or would not do that. Speak to that for a moment.

Dr. Page: I would be glad to, Dr. Allen. I will tell you, and the vast majority of people that I have ever known, I have studied this. For some reason I studied it long ago. I studied historical instances of suicide. There are three major mass suicides that have occurred in our history. Masada, a place called Gomley that nobody knows about, where almost as many people committed suicide as Masada, and then of course Jonestown, Guyana. There are other smaller groups on some Japanese islands who committed suicide so as not to be taken captive. The vast majority of suicides with which we are familiar are people who have lost touch with reality. Mental or emotional struggle has reached such a horrible point that they are not thinking straight anymore. I do believe that believers can come to that point of oppression, or confusion, or depression so much so that they are not thinking straight. I believe the vast majority of people who commit suicide have reached that point, and I do not believe that our Lord would hold against them the pain that led them to that point. I do not believe that at all. In fact, Scripture teaches in Romans that nothing shall separate us from the love of God.

Dr. Allen: Right, in addition to that though, some people think that as they have this conversation, that you cannot go to heaven if you commit suicide because you are committing a sin that you cannot ask forgiveness for. That is a nonsensical understanding of sanctification or salvation. I mean, most every Christian alive will die with some unconfessed sin in their life.

Dr. Page: That is right, but there are some theologies out there that say it is a mortal sin. There are a few denominations whereby you can lose your salvation very easily, and if any sin happens in your life—thought or un-thought, spoken or unspoken—you can lose it and you better get saved again. It is almost a daily salvific journey and that is not scriptural. It is just not scriptural. It is a hurtful thing when someone has committed suicide within your family and someone brings that up. If you are not theologically grounded and have a biblical understanding, it can be deeply devastating. That is why I said some of things in the book to help you realize, quit listening to people and start listening to God. Go to the Word of God and study it. You know, I remember doing a funeral of a suicide victim in South Carolina, and the church was filled with people of faith and people not of faith, people of various groups, and they were confused. I even brought up those things that I just spoke about. I said, “Who told you that?” I held up the Bible and I said, “Listen to what the Bible says.” All of the sudden I remember people writing me; Jewish people, Muslim people, they were all there. They said, “We have never heard people speak honestly, ever.” Look to the Word. Quit listening to people and listen to God.

Dr. Allen: That is the word I would use to describe this book: so honest. Honest about your story, honest about Melissa’s story, honest about letting the Scripture speak. Say a word, as we would wrap this conversation up, to those who may be contemplating suicide.

Dr. Page: First of all, there are a lot more of those than we think. We are living in a day of epidemic suicide, Dr. Allen. The chief of Chaplains of the U.S. Army said during the height of the Afghanistan and the Iraqi war that we are losing more men to suicide than we are to combat, particularly in the last few months and years. We do not know why, but the level of the young women committing suicide is taking a dramatic leap. I heard recently that for the first time suicide has replaced automobile accidents of young adults as [the top] cause of death. It is epidemic. So, many are out there pondering suicide. Whatever the societal pressures, the cultural pressures that are out there, many are opting for suicide. So many are pondering it. And I say to them, suicide is a permanent solution to a temporary problem. Come to Christ, listen to Christ. He can help you. There are God’s people who will help you. I am calling, as far as mental illness in general—specifically in deep depression—for churches to be places of help and hope. Don’t to sweep it under the rug; don’t act like it is something we cannot discuss, but talk about it, be honest, and deal with it. But please, call me. Call Dr. Allen. Call somebody. Call a pastor. Call somebody before you make this decision because, as I say in the book, you may not understand what you are going to leave behind. You may not know. You may think you are just getting out of a painful situation, but you have no idea what you are going to be doing to those who love you, and of the ongoing repercussions of what that will do. So please, give serious prayer and consideration to getting the help and hope that is in Christ and through God’s people.

Dr. Allen: Well, the book is a gift to the church, and a gift to humanity. Your book coupled with the much publicized tragedy with Rick Warren’s son has brought this to the forefront of the conversation in so many churches. I wish every seminary student would read this book; every father would read this book; every mother; because it is more than a story about a tragic death. It is a story about life, a story about parenthood, a story about struggling, and about loving one with struggles. Thank you for this book. May the Lord use it to increase and strengthen his kingdom. Thank you for the conversation.

Dr. Page: Thank you, Dr. Allen.